Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by throwaway9980 1152 days ago
The average roof has a lifespan at least an order of magnitude greater than a k8s cluster. Most roofs being put on today will outlast k8s itself.

Software is a liability, not an asset. Treating the construction and maintenance of this horrible liability knows as “code” is a complete misunderstanding of what software actual is.
2 comments
fdsalkjfdlkj 1152 days ago
It's just an example. Another is paint. The rule is close to but not exactly "if it lasts more than a year it has to be depreciated instead of expensed."

The book value of the k8s work could be completely expensed as soon as it is replaced.

Also, your belief that "software is a liability" is irrelevant. What matters is that tax law calls software an asset (as does most everyone else, even ones who fundamentally understand it).

link
throwaway9980 1152 days ago
> Also, your belief … is irrelevant.

This is true everywhere and always.

I agree with you, lots and lots of software definitely has the properties of an asset. There’s also plenty of software that’s hastily written, untested, and basically not fit for use beyond a short expiration date. More like a jug of milk with a shelf life than a fine grand piano with resale value.

link
jeremyjh 1152 days ago
If the software makes money for the business, it is an asset.
link
throwaway9980 1152 days ago
That seems like a very broad way of classifying assets.

Are people assets? Certainly not on the balance sheet I hope.

What about a contract? Is a contract an asset? I’m actually curious, not trying to be a smart ass.

link
DelaneyM 1152 days ago
The value people produce is an asset. After all, you don't own people, you buy their effort.

A contract can be an asset. Usually the unrealized future value of the agreement has value should you need to make a deemed disposition (or have some other valuation event). It gets very obviously complicated and fuzzy though, which is where accountants make the big bucks. It's pretty rare that a company chooses to make a contract valuable, but it often comes up in bankruptcy proceedings.

As an example of contracts having value, a few years ago I was involved in the acquisition of some media distribution assets, and one such asset was a transferable "MFN" contract with a major publisher. That was a very, very valuable asset.

link
piperswe 1152 days ago
Another instance of contracts having value: bonds and options are just contracts, and it would be insane to consider a bond to not be an asset.
link
cj 1152 days ago
A contract for a typical SaaS company, billed annually, is actually a liability (from an accounting perspective) up until the point where the contract has been completely fulfilled.

Others (say, an investor) might view a contract as an “asset” because of the future value it might bring, but not in a traditional accounting sense.

link