Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by hackerlight 1162 days ago
> If we cannot trust the judgement of the common folk, why have a democracy at all?

The fact that people are irrational is why we do not have a direct democracy. Representative democracy, and the existence of constraints in the form of constitution-type documents and term limits, are designed to limit the impact of temporal individual stupidity and crowd stupidity on global outcomes, by constraining the scope of immediate democracy.

> people defend censoring "misinformation" because people (supposedly) cannot discern it from "real" information.

This is overly flippant and strawman-like (conflating government censorship with private company moderation, for example) to what is a massive problem in the age of social media. Vaccine hesitancy, leading to hundreds of thousands of additional dead people, is due to misinformation. There are literal dead people as the end result of this misinformation. Now I for one would prefer that private companies do not censor misinformation, and instead focused on altering the viral dynamics. But this is not a topic to brush under the rug with denialism that misinformation is an actual thing.

1 comments

One of the most developed countries on the planet, Switzerland, has direct democracy. Which is one of the many reasons I’ve moved there.