Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by throwaway8503 1163 days ago
Purely as a matter of esoteric interest, does anyone know of any affordable photon counting devices?
3 comments

I think you’re looking for a lux meter. Precision is far rougher than single photons, but good enough for any human-scale use. It’s what you’d use for things like calibrating indoor lighting, quantifying the difference between a sunny day and moonlit night, or testing flashlights. Last I checked a good basic one was under $40.
Only for high energy photons.

https://gammaspectacular.com/

Do you mean a camera?
If there's a way to get an integer value on the number of photons per cell in a camera sensor, let me know
No but there is a way to get integer values for the photo-electrons per pixel.
I suppose there would be a rough conversion between that value and photon count (at some wavelength range). I just imagine the error bars to be very wide.
Not really, it depends from the application. Even something like 20 years ago the CCDs available at the time were capable of astrometric measure of star magnitudes with 1/100 of magnitude precision using some control stars.
You realize that light is actually electromagnetic radiation and there is no such thing as a physical photon right?
I think you're sort of half right
Aren't you being very particular? Just wave the mistake off, I say.
Everything in our universe is made up of waves. Does it really matter whether it's an oscillation in one field or another? Photons are discrete systems, can you clearly differentiate why anything else in the universe is "physical"?
Photons as an idea can make simulation easier, but it matters if someone is trying to 'count photons' and they don't exist.
How so? My understand is that a photon is a discrete packet of energy. Why can't I count those? If there is an excitation in the electromagnetic field, and then there is not, and then there is one - why are those not separate, countable photons?