Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by forrestthewoods 5245 days ago
Perforce is quite expensive, yes. I don't understand the rest of your comments though. I'm not sure why company size, code author, or profit margins are relevant. Perforce is used by every major gaming studio, Pixar, Nvidia, and many more.

If I were to make a snarky comment it would be that Git is for poor people and Perforce is what you use when you grow up. That's not an even remotely reasonable statement, but it does have a teeny, tiny hint of truth to it. :)
2 comments
malkia 5245 days ago
I love git, hg, svn, fossil but P4 is awesome.

I've used for 10+ at work, and it's easy to explain to anyone how to use it (from production to artist, and coders).

It has it's gotcha moments, but I haven't seen better. We normally go by 50-100GB depot, and then often whole branches of the game copied.

link
chubot 5245 days ago
I'm just pointing out the Perforce is making crazy profit, and somewhat ironically it's doing so more efficiently (I conjecture) than Facebook, which you are hearing a lot more about.

Perforce is a great system, but it's showing it's age by now. I think there is probably room for someone to make another product in the high end space and make boatloads of cash from big companies, but it's not easy.

link
nfg 5245 days ago
> Perforce is a great system, but it's showing it's age by now.

Care to elaborate? Do you mean in terms of distributed -vs- centralised repos?

link
chubot 5244 days ago
Yes partly. Doing lots of commits locally before pushing to others is definitely something I like.

Another part of it is working disconnected -- with so many people coding on their laptops that's actually a pretty common use case.

Also the lack of need to do sysadmin work on git/hg is really nice. I used to run the free Perforce server a long time ago for myself, but it was annoying to do the backups. With git or hg you get whole-repository backups for free.

The "big repository with all dependencies model" has its drawbacks but it's interesting that facebook finds a lot of use for it, and that git is unsuitable for it. Perforce is probably still their best choice in that case.

link
forrestthewoods 5244 days ago
The most recent version of Perforce added streams which is their primary answer to git and hg. Easy creation, management, and switching between branches. I've only used this at home and not in a large scale environment yet, but it's promising.

Later this year they are adding p4 Sandbox which allows for disconnected work. When that is complete and working I'm honestly not sure what advantage git will have left other than being free.

link