Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by lordnacho 1169 days ago
Worst interviews are ambushes. Things are going fine, you're discussing tech stuff, guy decides you need to "code" right now in an alien coding environment.

First time, guy asks me how I'd do some problem, I talk him through it, I mention there's an easy O(n^2) way but with a bit of thinking there's probably an nlogn way. He doesn't want to let me think for half a minute, just rushes me into the inefficient solution. So I do that, and at the end it's "oh I think there's a better way".

Second time I've been through a bunch of rounds, 3rd party recruiter calls me to ask to go into the office to meet the boss, to discuss terms and numbers. I get there, he wants to code some BS algorithm on a piece of paper. I do the whole thing, he finds a bug. Won't tell me what it is. As far as I can tell, he isn't a compiler. So I search around a bit, find the bug, whatever, I don't get why he can't just let it go when we've talked through the algo. So we go on, second problem, I nail it again. Again there's some bug. I tell him listen, if this wasn't on a damn piece of paper in crappy handwriting, it wouldn't be a problem. Why are you trying to hire a head of trading technology using a piece of paper and a pen?

Didn't get the job, funnily enough.

3 comments

>Worst interviews are ambushes.

That's a great description that hiring managers / HR / people who design and conduct interviews should contemplate. Are we ambushing candidates or are we seeking to understand their strengths and weaknesses?

I don't know why you'd ever do an ambush interview for a developer position. Programming is very much a 'think and plan' type of activity.

Actually, I wonder if the prevalence has anything to do with the fact that an ambush interview style has certain advantages if you're hiring an HR person and therefore the people designing interview norms think it's a good idea?

(I can see this style having some utility for positions where the candidate has to deal with high-stakes social situations with very little prep, like HR or PR. "Prove your ability to calmly handle the unexpected and reorient.")

I'm shocked at how many of the responses here describe ambush interviews, I did not know this was a thing! Thanks for sharing :)