Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by FireBeyond 1178 days ago
> Try a VW ID and see what you think of the software, in fact try any modern manufacturers software and compare it to Tesla. It’s always junk. The only reason the Polestar is close is because it’s native android running the show.

I don't always agree with Tesla's -UX- decisions, and things that are buried layers deep, but their UI is certainly one of the nicest, agreed. But there's more to it than that.

And if the response to that is "Just use voice control", well, then it doesn't matter anywhere near as much that they have the nicest UIs.

The big thing I notice is that a lot of Tesla owners are fully bought into the "dinosaur" hype and think that many Tesla features are exclusive to them.

Meanwhile, my non-Tesla has things like:

- Traffic sign recognition - my car talks to (well, listens to) the traffic lights in my city and actually will show a countdown until when they will change. It will even recognize school zone signs and (at least when they are connected to lights) will recognize when those are active (will display 'school' above the speed limit, regardless, and then blink that if it notes a blinking light associated with that sign).

- Adaptive blind spot - so nice. Speed differential low, or you're going faster? Will not activate, or only activate last moment. But if someone is blowing by you in the HOV lane, it will warn of them when they're still several hundred feet back.

- Laser headlights. Matrix headlights. Night vision with thermal imaging.

- Predictive active suspension - The car actively scans the road ahead with sensors and it will adjust suspension for poorer road conditions.

- The car can not just stop, but will actively swerve, if safe, around obstructions to avoid a collision, or even a parked car opening a door into traffic.

All this in the Model S price range.

5 comments

You know who else is fully bought into the "dinosaur" hype and think that many features are exclusive to them? Apple/iPhone users. Apple is constantly behind competitors when it comes to cameras and functionalities, but they are still the most valuable company in the world.
What kind of car is this? I’m looking for a non-Tesla right now, very curious what the hood options are
I'm going to guess Audi e-tron based on the feature list.
These are features on most of the mid to high end Audis.
What car do you have?
That could be a lot of mid-to-high end cars. Matrix headlight makes me think of Audi, but none of these features are especially cutting edge nowadays.
My Tesla Model 3 has matrix lights physically but not the software to make them actually useful beyond being really nice lights. It does not have any of the pixel control beyond the pointless light show which I have never even tried.
And a modern model S does not have those features and more?

(asking because I honestly don't know)

It can "sometimes" recognize traffic lights (I say sometimes, because it also recognizes railroad crossing lights as broken traffic lights).

It also doesn't have traffic light communication. Nor school zone identification.

Predictive active suspension - no. The car treats even road sealant at times as an obstruction.

Will not swerve around another vehicle - only AEB.

Predictive active suspension: https://www.findmyelectric.com/blog/tesla-adaptive-suspensio...

Ok, this is just a blog, but it seems to have it (for at least 2 years now)? Or am I missing something?

> Will not swerve around another vehicle

Huh?! Ever seen a recent FSD video? I've even seen it swerve around wildlife?

Tesla's Adaptive Suspension is essentially "adjustable suspension":

> new control settings for Standard and Sport modes allow the driver to adjust the suspension for a smoother or more “road aware” driving feel. Originally a move away from the control structure of the older Smart Air Suspension, the Adaptive Suspension is raised and lowered based on preference selections in the control panel (Never, Always, or Highway) rather than through ride height by increments.

The Audi system does that and a bunch more:

- raises the car for ingress and egress

- It's also meant to absorb the road's pitches and dips by prepping the chassis where appropriate.

- In comfort mode, the front camera pairs up with the steering, which allows the car to feel any unevenness and signal the system to respond accordingly.

- Audi also claims that a "curve-tilting function" cuts down on lateral acceleration felt by occupants.

- "Upon entering a curve, it elevates the side of the body on the outside of the curve and lowers the other side, thereby tilting it into the curve up to three degrees,"

and more.