Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by chimeracoder 1180 days ago
<insert obligatory comment triggering a debate over whether "Ceremony" is really a Joy Division song or a New Order song/>

"Disorder" might be my favorite Joy Divison song.

Hard to pick a favorite New Order song since they had so many different eras and styles. "Ceremony" is the best of their classic post-punk works. "True Faith" was an incredibly influential song musically despite being less-known. "Temptation" and "Sub-Culture" are works of art.

2 comments

"True Faith" is also notable for having a really fun music video, which is often projected during their live shows: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mfI1S0PKJR8

Picking favorite New Order tracks is especially difficult since many of their singles have multiple mixes, with substantial differences. For example I always prefer the gothier 12" remix of Sub-Culture, or the dancier Shep Pettibone remix of "True Faith". And meanwhile with some hits like "Bizarre Love Triangle" there are far too many versions to even keep track of...

Galaxie 500's cover is better than both

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=92Nkrav2-Aw

It's a masterpiece as well, for sure.

There are a lot of great covers of the tune. I love Dean Wareham's. Every time he plays it, he seems to find something new.

His cover tends toward melancholy. Peter Hook's, a little angry, sometimes triumphant. There's a cover by Day Wave that's almost happy. Several ambient covers that range from, I dunno, anhedonic to transcendent.