|
|
|
|
|
|
by stavros
1172 days ago
|
|
|
I'm convinced LLMs are amazing for search, because they're the only thing that managed to give me an answer when I was looking for some software I didn't know the general category name for. I described what I wanted the software to do, corrected its understanding with a few followup messages, and it gave me a list of alternatives that are exactly what I wanted, along with a category name. Google, in comparison, returned absolutely irrelevant SEO spam. |
|
|
Sometimes search means “I can sort of describe what I’m looking for, can you tell me what it’s called?”. LLMs excel here. I told GPT4 I’m doing computer animation and want to do smooth blending, it told me that’s called “interpolation”, I asked for some common terms in the literature about this to help me look and it told me about LERP, SLERP, quaternions, splines, Beziers, keyframes, inverse kinematics, and motion capture. All useful jumping-off points. (A subset of this type of search is “I know what this is called, can you tell me more about it?”. This is probably the place where LLMs sell snake oil the most; they always provide a convincing explanation of the thing, but there’s no guarantee on veracity.)
Other times, search means “I have a specific phrase and I want to find occurrences of it”. LLMs aren’t just bad at this, they are constitutionally incapable of it. The way you build an LLM necessarily involves taking all specific phrases and occurrences thereof, and blending them up into a word slurry that is then condensed and abstracted into floating point weights. It no longer has the specifics to give you. It’s a shame that search engines have let this task (“ctrl-f the web”) fall by the wayside. It’s probably a large part of why people think Google search sucks now, it certainly is for me. (There’s this one essay about the Harappan civilization that I used to be able to find by searching for “strange builders mist of time”, I definitively remember that exact phrase working for me many years ago, and now it does not work and I cannot find that essay anymore.)