Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by josscrowcroft 5253 days ago
Upvoted just for this absolute gem:

[...] it also depends on where you are on Maslow’s hierarchy of needs. The lower on the pyramid your product is, the crappier it can look. If your product is core to helping people make money, pirate movies, or sell your useless couch, you don’t need a designer. But if you’re high on the pyramid, ugly/clunky UI makes it impossible to for people to see your vision.

Never heard this advice in reference to Maslow, but it's truth! I should print this up on cards and give it to a load of my tech and designer friends.

The entire "It's like [Craigslist/Amazon/eBay]... but with a beautiful design/UI!" fallacy falls to its knees with this paragraph.

1 comments

I think that design could still be really helpful if its helps achieve one of those core 'needs.' Craigslist leaves alot to be desired when searching for apartments (my only experience with it) compared to Hipmunk's hotel search, which plots the results on a map with color/size coding.
I recently discovered padmapper while apt hunting, and it's a godsend. It scrapes craigslist for data and posts it to a map.

The killer feature is obviously to be able to look at a region and see what's available, but the filtering options are also way easier to use than craigslist's rather pathetic interface.

This is funny because housingmaps, mapping craigslist listings to google maps was the original mashup. The guy went and worked for google because he said he didn't think there were any good barriers to entry to run the idea as a business.
Craigslist is not just about apartments though. It's a general purpose online classified ad site. Building a lot of location plotting features might not have any relevance for 80-90% of the listings.