Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by atoav 1178 days ago
Sure. I as a musician that practised for years to play the right note in the right way the right moment will truly appreciate it when the unique style I developed with my band over years of work and sweat will be cloned in mere seconds by a multi-national corporation and their AI. Or it could be a 13 year old teenager that has the AI create music in the style of someone else.

Not that I am against sampling and remixing, but I have yet to see that AI based cloning of music can truly become an artform with it's own merits like sampling has become — or whether it will destroy the filaments of reality to such a degree music will have to become something entirely different than it is now.

What I am sure of, is that those who have power today will find ways to hold that power tomorrow.

3 comments

And I'm sure all of the musicians you "took inspiration from" are happy about you stealing from them.
How are you so sure? You've never even heard their music.
You are not the authority on what counts as an "artform of its own".

I agree with your last statement though.

I am the authority of what counts as an artform of its own — to myself. I mean I also have a MA in arts, so I know about art forms, but I didn't attempt to represent an authority here. So I am sorry if you perceived I was acting as an "authority" when in fect I was speaking a out my very own perspective and nothing more.
There will be two groups of people: those who figure out how to use AI to their benefit and those who don't
And those who figure it out and still won't benefit, because bigger entites do what bigger entites always did when technological promises loomed at the horizon.