Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by 0dayz 1178 days ago
Just the title feels misleading, Yugoslavia didn't exist in practical terms when Nato bombed Serbia (Croatia, Macedonia and Slovenia was de facto gone).

I've to this day not heard a single good argument from the "anti-imperialists" of what the world should have done after multiple attempts with large peace treaties being violated.

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=czQrU0OPIR8

Here's a much better video showing the time line.

1 comments

> Just the title feels misleading, Yugoslavia didn't exist in practical terms when Nato bombed Serbia (Croatia, Macedonia and Slovenia was de facto gone).

That's needlessly pedantic, and wrong.

The Socialist Federal Republic of Yugoslavia, the union of 6 Balkan countries, didn't exist anymore in 1999. But the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia, the union of Serbia and Montenegro, existed between 1992 and 2003. Colloquially, they're both referred to as Yugoslavia, and it's clear from the date and context which one is referenced.

> Here's a much better video showing the time line.

I haven't seen the video from the OP yet, but this one from Johnny Harris, while slick and well produced, refers to SFR Yugoslavia being communist. It was actually a more liberal form of socialism (the S in SFRY) than communist USSR countries ever enjoyed. Tito famously established the Non-Aligned Movement of countries that rejected both Western and Eastern influence.

Overall, it gets many things right, but my history knowledge in the period isn't great to fact-check what else it got wrong.

>That's needlessly pedantic, and wrong.

I'm sorry but you don't see the irony of saying my point is "pedantic" and then you go well ashctually.

And even if we skip past that I'm not wrong since I said de facto not de jure (which even then you are wrong, _socialist_ federal republic is not the same as federal republic, that's like saying USSR is the same as modern day Russia).

The video is about the war not the state, since the war didn't happen during titos reign.

Hence why I think you can gloss over the oversimplification.