Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by panarky 1174 days ago
The fallacy of false equivalence systematized in code.

Now one side can spew as much disinfo and incitement to violence as it likes, and any algorithm change that prevents this shit from getting amplified will be rejected as bias.

BSaaS = Both Sides as a Service

5 comments

This shouldn't really be a surprise to anyone. It was reported years ago that Twitter was unable to cut down on hate speech because the automated systems they developed triggered too many [debatably false] positives on Republican politicians and that was bad for the company's reputation. If Twitter wanted to prevent future code changes from impacting that approach, there needed to be something like this in the code or tests.
Not sure why you got downvoted, you're absolutely correct.
Well, technically they are looking for relative changes, not equal total exposures.
I don't see an unbiased way to tell which "side" releases more disinformation and incitement to violence. Even deciding what counts as disinformation is hard (e.g. does it have to be literally false or just cause false beliefs in the reader?).
One way to tell would be to look at which side is incited to violence more often.

It turns out, according to the FBI (which is a conservative organization historically and exclusively run by conservatives), right wing extremism and violence is in fact the biggest domestic terror threat in the US, and it's currently growing [1]. FBI Director Wray gave this testimony after a right wing domestic terror attack was carried out that aimed to topple the US government. Not much has changed since then [2]. Since the former President's indictment the other day, the right-wing violent rhetoric has also ratcheted up a notch, so we can expect right-wing violence to follow.

Notably, we can confidently say this doesn't happen on the left, as when Hillary lost they did not launch an assault against the Capitol as the right did. Instead, they knit pink hats and had a march.

(PS before anyone whattabouts the George Floyd protests, the FBI doesn't see them the same way [3])

https://apnews.com/article/fbi-chris-wray-testify-capitol-ri...

https://news.yahoo.com/right-wing-extremists-responsible-for...

https://www.fbi.gov/file-repository/fbi-dhs-domestic-terrori...

Yeah but despite all that they should still give leftists a platform to tweet.