Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by SimHacker 5247 days ago
But you can be 99.994% sure they're writing your plan text user name and password into their logs if you're using get, and if somebody breaks in and gets them, then they have your password, even if those passwords are properly hashed in the user database.
1 comments

No, I wouldn't be 99.994% sure of that at all. In fact, I would assume that if they are suggesting that people use GET, that they are in fact not logging the query params, as any security audit would catch that.

And again, if they are compromised, then they are compromised. It doesn't matter if they have logging disabled, someone who would have access to the logs also has access to either the httpd account or the root account. Either way, they can already read your plaintext usernames and passwords directly when they are being submitted. Of course, they don't need your username and password anyways, as they already have full access to the system.

Picking a comment at random to thank you for at least trying to explain to people why their assumption of what's being logged relates in no way to security.

At least one person appreciates someone taking the time to correct this rather serious misunderstanding.