[saagarjha]

People have done this in the past, at this point most people are just going to meme about it rather than respond. The response that they get is always “if it’s so easy why don’t you hack it?” which is quite frankly more effort than anyone wants to spend on an OS that doesn’t really harm anyone just sitting by itself layering all sorts of “mitigations” on itself. They’re basically completely divorced from what any real-world exploit these days looks like (blind ROP, really?) or how attackers work (“99% secure will stop them!!”) but somehow always really convoluted and optimized at stopping one very specific exploit flow rather than a general technique. The real solution for stopping ROP/JOP is going to be CFI, shadow stacks, etc. rather than trying to kludge something on hardware that doesn’t support it.

[beachhead]

I hear you. I guess I'd just like to see more hacking and less of the memes. For me I think again that it would help more than hurt.

I'm an old man now and maybe I've gone a bit soft but I don't see much benefit in mocking and am more interested in helping even if that means wasting a bit of time.

[saagarjha]

Someone might make a CTF challenge out of it someday I guess.