Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by mmmmmbop 1184 days ago
I agree with the sentiment, but it's not correct that price dumping is illegal for physical products.

Trade treaties and WTO rules cover dumping in international trade for obvious reasons, but to my knowledge, there's no law in the major western jurisdictions covering domestic dumping.

2 comments

Domestic dumping may be prohibited as predatory pricing under anti-trust, depending on the circumstances, including the pricer needing to have market power.
Right, but there is zero differentiation there between physical and virtual products. GP implied that there is some sort of protection against price dumping of physical products that doesn't exist for virtual products.
The differentiation is in your choice of terminology. "Virtual" products have zero marginal cost, and the statute mentions marginal cost. The statute doesn't have to mention "virtual" products because it mentions marginal cost.
https://www.ftc.gov/advice-guidance/competition-guidance/gui... notes that there are dumping restrictions, but that courts rarely find firms in violation.

Asking ChatGPT "What is the case law around single-firm predatory pricing?" provides a number of examples, including the tests used by various Western court systems. (Though do note that ChatGPT is not a lawyer, and this is not legal advice!)

Correct, anti-trust law can introduce a lot of rules prohibiting actions that would be fine if it weren't for the monopolistic position of the actor. But as mentioned in the other comment, there's no differentiation there between physical and virtual products.