Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by femto113 1176 days ago
Managers don't actually want estimates. A genuine "estimate" would be a probability distribution over a range of dates, with some point identified as the most likely delivery date and a roughly even chance of being early or late relative to that point. What they actually want is "the earliest date you cannot currently prove to be infeasible", which essentially is the near end of that date range, so there's a roughly 100% chance you'll come in after it. I've had exactly one manager who (after I explained this) admitted that was actually what he wanted, but I couldn't convince him of the utility of asking for genuine estimates.
3 comments

You cannot prove anything either way so that's also a moot point. If someone can prove you wrong on it they should do the estimate and if they can't then anything works.

We're all in the world of microservices in large orgs that don't talk to each other. Who knows what will be impacted...

Reminds me of bureaucracies deciding that staff should have the “Worst possible equipment they cannot prove actually stops them working.”
Bingo. And not only is it a probability distribution, it's a constantly changing one.