Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by crop_rotation 1179 days ago
If there is a magical way to gauge character in a short amount of time then sure, however I doubt most people will do any better than a coin flip when asked to predict the "character" of someone without having known the person deeply.
2 comments

> If there is a magical way to gauge character in a short amount of time then sure

This is key. Many universities that claim to do "holistic reviews" don't have the time or resources to actually do holistic reviews. University of Washington is an example. UW gives application reviewers 8 minutes per application. And who are these reviewers? Do they have the knowledge and experience to do a "holistic review" in 8 minutes, including reading essays and personal statements and so on? Nope! They hire grad students, retirees etc. to act as application reviewers [1].

[1] https://www.king5.com/article/news/local/a-look-inside-admis...

Character gauging is basically does the prospective student show enough characteristics that upper middle class people have.