Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by hsn915 1187 days ago
What about any of this prohibits it from being a library?

https://lucene.apache.org/core/

This is the Java library that ES is based on. Without even having to look at it I can make the following judgement:

It should be easy to port to any language.

It's open source, and it's Java. Java has no special features that makes it impossible or particularly difficult to replicate this functionality in any other compiled language, like C, Rust, Go, or any other language that is not 100x wasteful of system resources.
3 comments
porker 1187 days ago
> This is the Java library that ES is based on.

Based on, but Elasticsearch is not just a server wrapped around the library. Features ES has are not in Lucene, otherwise anyone could release a competitor by wrapping the library.

> It should be easy to port to any language.

You win the "Most Hacker News comment of March 2023" award. This thread is talking about less effort, and you bring up porting Lucene to another programming language.

link
lmz 1186 days ago
I thought it was already ported to other languages eg. https://clucene.sourceforge.net/

Not sure about feature parity though.

link
prmoustache 1186 days ago
> Based on, but Elasticsearch is not just a server wrapped around the library. Features ES has are not in Lucene, otherwise anyone could release a competitor by wrapping the library.

Those competitors exist.

link
tm-guimaraes 1187 days ago
Go is not less wasteful than java, both are garbage collected and their memory pressure depend highly on the given workload, and the runtime of the program. But java allow more GC tuning and even different GCs for different use cases (ie: shenadoah and ZGC favor very low latency workloads, while the default G1GC favors throughout (not that simple, but you get the point))

Regardless, Java/Go tier of performance is good enough for this kind of thing.

link
hsn915 1186 days ago
I was referring to Ruby/Python when I said 100x wasteful languages.
link
re-thc 1186 days ago
Problem is it doesn't support HA. You're stuck on that single server model. Upgrades always = downtime = painful. You're also missing things like self-healing and your Lucense index can corrupt.

Real world experience says better to move away from it e.g. lots of self-hosted Atlassian instances over the years. Lucene was a major pain point.

link