Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by paulusthe 1187 days ago
The short answer is we don't know for certain.

The long answer is that today's inflation doesn't seem to be monetary in cause, because nearly every country is experiencing inflation simultaneously. If the Fed had printed too much money and that was why the US was inflated, that dynamic shouldn't really affect, say, Germany, or Brazil. (Caveats abound, of course). Despite that, we're seeing nearly every major country have similar and sustained rates of inflation across monetary policy regimes.

So, we know there's been something that affected everyone globally, and that's obviously supply chain disruptions along with gas and oil price changes due to Ukraine. Fed policy didn't cause the inflation, something bigger than the Fed did.

The question then is can the Fed fix it. The answer here is maybe. The Fed has tools to fix inflation - when the inflation is caused by monetary policy reasons - and those tools should, all else held equal, reduce inflation eventually.

The real question is whether or not the Fed is the best entity suited to tackling today's inflation. Politically, it's very easy to just delegate all that stuff to the Fed so that it becomes some technocratic thing that's essentially beyond the scope of normal politics. This is what Reagan did in the early 80s. But in terms of actually fixing the underlying problems, I don't know how much impact the Fed can have.

Raising rates won't make supply chains readjust to today's geopolitical environment, or hire more truckers to move long-stored inventory. It will fix the monetary part of the inflation, but to get back to your question, nobody really knows what the monetary part is. It's less than we'd normally think, but we don't know precisely.

3 comments

> The long answer is that today's inflation doesn't seem to be monetary in cause, because nearly every country is experiencing inflation simultaneously.

Every country printed money during Covid.

While this is true, the size of direct fiscal in the US i.e. stimmie checks was enormous. I think the original poster is correct, I encourage anybody in this thread to look into what happened with used cars. At times that accounted for as much as 1.5% of the month on month inflation figures.

A globalised supply chain was disrupted by covid and that exposed some pretty gnarly non-linearities in how pricing happens. Combined with an explosion in shipping prices that actually pre-cluded low inflation areas from exporting their disinflation to high inflation e.g. I've linked elsewhere charts on shipping costs. Have a look at a USDJPY chart and wonder why the US wasn't loading up on cheap Japanese goods..

Correct - once the world saw the Fed dumping $1 trillion into the money supply to prevent a collapse due to Covid in 2020, everybody else did as well. It takes time for that to make its way through the pricing system (bearing in mind inflation is measured over the last 12 months, its a lagging indicator).

There are also demand factors as well, but most of what we are seeing is monetary in origin, raising interest rate is also somewhat "demand" driven, in that the big trigger there was the market for buying MBS (packages of loans mostly made by banks and S&L) market froze and then spiked up significantly.

The Fed printing money affects the whole world as long as the US dollar is the global reserve currency.
I do agree, though the US does export it's inflation with a lot of the world trading in $.