[Ancapistani]

Yep.

> They are almost certainly migrant children who need the money because they’ve been placed with guardians who themselves are barely getting by

s/migrant/poor, but otherwise I 100% agree.

Kids from poor families want to be able to help with money if they can. Their contributions do help, too, and I don't think that's a bad thing in most cases.

Growing up poor, realizing your parents' financial situation, working hard to contribute to it, and then busting your ass to build a live that's better than your parents... that's the American Dream that I knew growing up. It's also the story of the vast majority of successful local entrepreneurs that I know in my local area.

I don't want that to go away. I think it's an important part of our culture.

> or are exploiting the children by making them work off a debt

I'm very confident that this happens. I don't have a good feel for how often, but I doubt it's even close to the majority case. I'm sure it still happens, though, and that's something that I fully support aggressively stamping out.

[mschuster91]

> Growing up poor, realizing your parents' financial situation, working hard to contribute to it, and then busting your ass to build a live that's better than your parents..

The problem is, it perpetuates the cycle of poverty. Dropping out of school at age 16 or whatever to help your parents make rent by slaving away in a supermarket stocking shelves will stunt your intellectual and career growth for decades, because without an actual education (be it trades or academia) it will be really hard to access better-paying jobs.

[Ancapistani]

> Dropping out of school at age 16 or whatever to help your parents make rent by slaving away in a supermarket stocking shelves will stunt your intellectual and career growth for decades, because without an actual education (be it trades or academia) it will be really hard to access better-paying jobs.

Compared to what we, the HN community, expects - yeah, I agree 100%.

Compared to what this community expects... it's not so clear.

We're making a lot of assumptions: that these children are dropping out of school, that the purpose of their working is to help feed their family, that they have better opportunities available to them, that the children and their parents want the same things as we do, etc.

The reality is that their parents likely never graduated high school either. There's no reason to think that these kids are choosing work over school, as opposed to doing both - which obviously would negatively impact their ability to succeed at school, but that's not the same thing as dropping out.

If these kids grow into adults who have graduated high school, they'll likely end up providing a more stable foundation for their children, so they can focus on school more than they were able to. They'll be more likely to push their kids to go to college, and to enter a field with higher qualification requirements like medicine, law, finance, or tech.

This is how immigrant communities have always worked, to the point that it's a stereotype. There's a reason second- and third-generation immigrants consistently outperform "native" groups in terms of both educational and professional attainment.

[mrguyorama]

As someone who got hurt by it, no, we should not keep around a system that saddles 10 year olds with extreme money anxiety because their parents are poor. America is stupid rich, we can easily support those families and attempt to insulate literal children from such anxieties.

It's not an important part of our society for an underclass to suffer FFS