Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by InclinedPlane 5261 days ago
What's Obama's long game on signing NDAA 2012? There's no excuse for that.
2 comments

The National Defense Authroization Act basically keeps in existence and funds the US military every year. Not signing it would've been a poorly chosen battle.

At the end of the day, not only do we have a divided system of power by design, Congress is the first among coequal powers in that design. Laying all the blame at the feet of the president for Congress enacting bad law makes no senss. I think some people love our system in theory but don't like it in practice.

There is no excuse for signing a law which effectively puts the US under martial law.

Period.

It's a budget bill; it gets enacted every year to fund the military. It must be signed eventually (and in this case, on the very last day). Blame your entire government for putting things like the infinite detention of citizens inside of a budget bill.
I'm not sure why I got downvoted; there's nothing inaccurate about what I said. Don't blame the messenger.
Then why did he pressure congress into making the rules even hazier so he could detain Americans as well?
I do blame everyone who had fingerprints on it. Obama was not obliged to sign it. He did.
> It's a budget bill

That got to be the stupidest excuse to introduce new horrible laws.