Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Rury 1195 days ago
No, storing everything in one account at one institution is a risky strategy. You're conflating what you want (something without risk), with something that fundamentally has risk anyways. You take a risk anytime you decide to do something with money, whether that's storing it under a mattress, giving you wallet to your kids, investing in a 401k, or putting money in a bank. There fundamentally is no such thing as a risk free investment when it comes to money. Even treasury bonds have risk to them, especially speaking in real terms.
1 comments

You're talking about financial risk like it's physics. Consider that financial risk is a psychological tool we invented to balance human behavior and we can reshape the tool whenever we want.

If you can consider that perspective, think about the activities we want to incentivize vs disincentivize in helping us decide when we _should_ reshape that tool.

Are simple bank deposits really something we want people to feel shaky about now and in the future??

> Are simple bank deposits really something we want people to feel shaky about now and in the future??

There is a strong argument for "yes": it will cause people to consider their (now extant) alternatives and some fraction of those people will choose something else, loosening the stranglehold that retail banking has on routine business transactions.

And what are the less risky alternatives to having money in a bank? Fucking Bitcoin?
Using a narrow/full reserve bank.
The Fed has gone out of its way several times to ban full reserve and narrow banks from ever getting access to Fed reserves.
No, normal bitcoin. It doesn't take much to be less risky than "you might have all of it frozen at any time by factors wholly outside of your control".

Or Ether. Or DAI. Or USDC if that's your risk appetite (the diversification of the storage of which is abstracted away already, as you will note it has regained its peg before SVB even reopened under FDIC management). Or a lot of other choices that present themselves.