Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by cmdialog 1201 days ago
Just because you aren't clever enough to use it as a hacking tool doesn't also mean that others aren't. You can easily do basic things like snatch NFC data. Or duplicate the RF transmit signal for someone else's garage doors. I think if you exercise a little imagination you can see how it could be used nefariously.

And even still I would never support banning the device.

2 comments

you could say the same for RPis, arduinos, or even just 555 timers -- it's still ridiculous to ban something that provides functionality that is trivial to replicate elsewhere.

the gimmick of the flipper is that it does a lot of things in one unit -- every one of those singular functions is easy to do elsewhere, and often less hobbled by the intrinsically low-power nature of the flipper.

That’s an unhelpfully overly-reductive position. Nobody is hacking garage doors with a 555.

In the same vein - AirTags are considerably easier to covertly place on someone else than other asset tracking systems. Yes you can accomplish something similar with either but the likelihood of it being used for unintended purposes increases with the convenience and ease of doing so.

> Nobody is hacking garage doors with a 555.

I'd honestly be surprised if no one has made a device to open garage doors with a 555 timer in it somewhere.

Don't garage doors use rotating keys, like car fobs?
There is alternative firmware that allows you to do some things with rolling codes. Most of the cool stuff the flipperzero can do can be found here - https://github.com/djsime1/awesome-flipperzero
Modern ones do, old ones do not
yes they do
It depends on the garage door opener.
Sure but most use rolling codes. Y'all can downvote all you like, it's still true, and downvotes won't change that.
The parent's comment was reasonably stated, and you haven't challenged its factuality. Also, you don't know that they downvoted you.

Regardless, what you said implies that no more than a negligible amount of garage doors don't use rolling codes, since the reason for my question was security related. If that's not true, I therefore wouldn't say your comment was strictly true.

All this is to say, votes up or down aren't that important. The attitude seems unwarranted.