Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by SeanAnderson 1204 days ago
...but there's a rotating hotdog. That's not a sandwich.
3 comments

I agree. People always talk about technicalities, ingredients, structure, etc. in this argument.

For me, the main reason why a hotdog isn't a sandwich is that you can't use the two interchangeably. I would never go up to a hotdog stand and ask for a sandwich.

Right. That's why hotdogs are not even food, or organic matter. I would never go up to a hotdog stand and ask for organic matter.
I think hot dogs are vegetarian but not vegan. As in, the stuff in a hotdog may or may not require the killing of the animal.
Please keep political flamethrowing off HN.

(Although I agree)

A sandwich is not an ontological category and should be eradicated.
Agreed, please send me all of the hotdogs for safe disposal. Also bratwursts, especially bratwursts