[keithalewis]

Same here. Sloppily written with very little content. If the author can't take the time to proofread his own paper why should anyone else waste their time?

[adamnemecek]

Ok read the Persi Diaconis one https://arxiv.org/abs/1206.3620.

You are right, it can be more polished but also it covers quite a lot and it was surprisingly hard to fit it all in.

The main response I have been getting though is "I won't believe this until I see the implementation" so I have been concentrating on that.