Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by bluSCALE4 1198 days ago
Cheap filters don't do much and the more expensive ones don't remove chlorine.
2 comments

It's really shocking how ineffective things like pitcher filters are when compared to a quality cartridge filter. The pitcher filters really do practically nothing.
Hard disagree. My tap water has a strong chlorine taste, I hate it. In my Brita pitcher, it's totally gone. Just tastes like water again.

It's the total opposite of "practically nothing", it does exactly what I bought it for -- effectiveness 100%.

There's no question that Brita filters improve water taste by reducing chlorine/chloramine levels, and they will remove relatively large particulates, but they pale in comparison to proper pressure-driven cartridge filter systems if you start looking at comparisons for other contaminants.
Sure, but for people who are getting perfectly safe water from their municipal water supply, and just want to get rid of the chlorine taste -- that's where pitcher filters work perfectly. You don't need anything else.
It’s still probably not doing anything, chlorine readily evaporates out of water left in a pitcher. It’s a common technique used by indoor growers of certain plants - leave a bucket out for a day.
I can taste the water 5 minutes after it goes through the filter. The chlorine is gone. (Which is not the case if I pour it into a glass.) It has nothing to do with how long it sits around for.

I find it strange you're insisting filters don't work when one can tell from taste that they clearly do. And scientifically, activated carbon absorbs chlorine -- that's not a myth. So everything checks out.

Pitcher filters work for chlorine.

Sure, they work for chlorine, but there are plenty of other issues (arsenic, PFCs, other VOCs, glyphosates, TTHMs, lead for non 'Elite' Brita filters) that Brita filters are woefully inadequate to address.
Are any of those issues for something like the NYC municipal water supply?

I think most people buy filter pitches to fix the taste of water. Not for health or safety reasons.

Yes it will. Any carbon filter will remove chlorine, it's impossible for it not to.

Cheap filters improve taste, not water quality. And in most places that's all you need.

Thanks for clarifying.