[ascagnel_]

> How is that comparable? iPhones, cars, clothes and much more are available in more than one color as well.

The iPhone, the car, the clothing, etc., are all functionally identical and frequently, but not always, cost the same amount. Pokemon is different in that the two versions of each game contain all the creatures, but artificially exclude some from being caught in each title, which is absolutely a dark pattern.

> I don't know anyone that actually bought both color editions of the same generation game.

I'm not sure when they started the practice, but the most recent revision of Pokemon includes a SKU that includes both colors.

https://twitter.com/nintendouk/status/1532018639565627399?

[lxgr]

> Pokemon is different in that the two versions of each game contain all the creatures, but artificially exclude some from being caught in each title, which is absolutely a dark pattern.

This is to get you to trade with your friends! The same thing is true for the three starter Pokémon – the only way to log all three is to trade with other players.

How would you even trade with yourself?

[mrguyorama]

Many people had to buy a second console and the other game if they wanted to fill out the pokedex.

[bentley]

I’m sure Nintendo wouldn’t have complained if people did that, but trades with friends were how the game was marketed: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T3Oh4YiMNNw

I was as big a Pokémon freak as anyone, lived in an extremely rural area, and still managed to complete the Pokédex without duplicate/paired games by trading with friends. (And nobody had to complete the Pokédex anyway! The games had a complete storyline without it.)

[mod50ack]

That was something that played on Pokémon as a social phenomenon. And, more than that, you didn't absolutely need to do that to play and enjoy the game. It was a multiplayer element. If you were a diehard, yeah, you could buy a second Game Boy and a second game, but that would require playing the full game twice to get all the exclusives in both. That was beyond what the developers expected the player to do. All of that would make the game harder!

On the other hand, players of FTP games are encouraged to make micropayments, which make those games "easier."

[lesuorac]

Definitely much better in the good ol' days where games didn't get patches and you could use glitches to get all 151.