Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by javajosh 1196 days ago
Yes, and when a forest burns down I call it the destruction of a forest even though it can grow back because that's how language is used.
2 comments

Even if you're talking about the fires in Yellowstone in 1988, the only way to call that "destruction of the forest" is if you define the forest as being the trees. That's a defensible choice.

(And temperate forests "burn down" all the time as part of their normal operations.)

But you can't define the biosphere as "the species that go extinct in a particular scenario". You're stuck with the whole thing, which is not going to notice whatever humans do. It would make as much sense to call it "destruction of the biosphere" if I moved a rock thirty feet.

Burning down is part of the natural lifecycle of many forests, and they actually suffer when modern land management stops natural fires.