Ask HN: Tailscale vs. Twingate?

[cscheueuer]

I was considering Tailscale, but their lack of DNS based routing is a huge turn off. I'm curious to hear from folks who have used Twingate or Tailscale at work which they like better and why?

[jarym]

For work, Twingate hands-down - the DNS routing as you mentioned is a huge plus in fragmented networks like the ones I frequently work in. Admins seem to like its UI and ability to set policies that are effective without upsetting users like me.

[sconi]

why not something other than twingate or tailscale?

[cscheueuer]

I'm wide open to any recommendation you have. These are just the two products that seem to come up most when I ask people for recommendations.

[sconi]

whats the use case? how many users?