Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by throwaway384629 1209 days ago
IMHO, you are the one who started comparing India Democracy with United States.

Also, I can ignore the papers for a moment. Can you tell me how many unscripted press conferences PM Modi did in last 8 years? Please don't count 1-1 interviews to Movie stars, or 1-1 scripted meetings in closed tv studios. I am asking for any public press conferenced where he is taking questions from 5-6 journalists form different organizations. The one hour radio monolog also does not count as a press conference.

To know why open press conferences are important for a democracy, you can read more here:

https://www.principlesofdemocracy.org/government-dem

1 comments

The government talks through its official channels, such as cabinet ministers, spokespersons and secretaries, and also Prime minister. What makes you think the Foreign/Finance/Defence/Home ministry statement is any less than a statement from PM himself?
Yes, there should be channels and delegation. But PM is also answerable to people and should appear to take questions from press. Giving a statement is not same as answering open questions from press.

United States also have different official channels and they all do their thing on their level. But that does not mean that PM/President gets a free run.

"With great power comes great responsibility"

> Yes, there should be channels and delegation. But PM is also answerable to people and should appear to take questions from press. Giving a statement is not same as answering open questions from press.

People have voted and they are okay with his decisions. He got more votes than his previous elections

> United States also have different official channels and they all do their thing on their level. But that does not mean that PM/President gets a free run.

Who decides that? Only elections can. Let's see what happens in the next general elections

> "With great power comes great responsibility"

Yes, CBI had to take some unpopular decisions. But they did

>> People have voted and they are okay with his decisions. He got more votes than his previous elections

>> Who decides that? Only elections can. Let's see what happens in the next general elections

Seems like we have went full circle. So I am pasting my comment again.

"The Nazi Party’s meteoric rise to power began in 1930, when it attained 107 seats in Germany’s parliament, the Reichstag. In July 1932, the Nazi Party became the largest political party in the Reichstag with 230 representatives" Sounds very similar, but above is from Holocaust encyclopedia. [1]

>> Yes, CBI had to take some unpopular decisions. But they did

CBI is BJP and BJP is CBI. [2]

[1] https://encyclopedia.ushmm.org/content/en/article/the-nazi-r...

[2] https://twitter.com/narendramodi/status/349075193714577408