[DiabloD3]

I've tried it. You can't really port magit from Emacs, its workflow depends entirely on how Emacs works (and this is a good thing, mind you). Neogit just feels awkward to use IMO from a vim perspective.

That said, I'm happy with Fugitive. It does the job in a way I'd expect from a vim plugin.

[pmoriarty]

There's nothing Magit (or emacs) does that can't be done in vim, and vice-versa.

It's just a matter of having the will to do it and putting in the time.

I say this as a huge fan of both editors. They are both so powerful they can do just about anything.

[klibertp]

That's not quite true for original Vim. The developer experience for writing plugins is incomparable; VimL lacks good ways of abstracting and composing behavior, while Emacs Lisp gives you just about everything a modern language should, including sophisticated object system with multimethods and multiple inheritance. The built-in debugger for Elisp is not on the level of JetBrains IDEs, but it provides all the typical functionalities and is GUI-driven, in contrast to Python's pdb or Ruby pry.

NeoVim is an entirely different beast, and I heard good things about its way of handling plugin development.