Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Scoundreller 1216 days ago
iunno, setting up a custom ROM is the first thing I do on any wifi router I buy. Haven't really touched the concept on my phone, but it's totally something I've done for security reasons.
1 comments

I can totally see doing it on a router, but I'm scared to do it on a phone because I've heard too many horror stories about banking apps and similar refusing to run if they detect they're running on a rooted phone.

I only have a smartphone in order to use all of the apps that people assume you'll be able to install. If a significant percentage of those won't work on a custom ROM, I may as well not have the device at all.

(It's entirely possible that my fears are overblown, but that I have them is suggestive of how far from mainstream custom roms are.)

It's fairly easy to bypass most of these with Magisk modules, like universal safetynet fix.
That's great, and something that I may eventually consider doing, but that doesn't help the average user who just wants to keep using their perfectly decent phone. Rooting their device and installing a custom rom is complicated enough without having to go through the process of installing extra modules.
> but that I have them is suggestive of how far from mainstream custom roms are.

Totally. I think ROMs like /e/ OS and CalyxOS are actually getting close to giving the same experience as stock ROMs, though (if you choose a phone that is supported, that it).

Let's hope it keeps moving forward! Repairable phones + long term support with custom ROM sounds great IMO!