Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by fr0sty 1218 days ago
https://www.poynter.org/fact-checking/2023/why-train-derailm...

Most derailments are in train yards. Few cause injuries, fewer cause deaths, and only a handful involve hazardous substances. I don't say that to downplay the mess in OH/PA, but just to make sure the base-rate is understood.

And if you want to compare to europe it looks like US freight rail volume is at least 6x as large. Also no idea if/how they count "fender bender" derailments in switching yards. US standard is >$12k in damage according to TFA.

1 comments

A couple months ago I watched an amateur train nerd on youtube cover a derailment that dumped a load of bitumin/tar into a river and destroyed a bridge. This kind of thing happens pretty commonly. No national news covered it, only a couple of local news stations, at least from what I could find on youtube/googling.

It's confusing to me why this specific incident got so much attention.

Maybe it should be confusing to you why more such harmful derailings are not getting as much attention
Link? That sounds like a channel I’d be interested in

And this got the attention it did because it’s far more severe then one load of tar/bitumen in a river - and far more toxic made potentially worse from the choice to. Burn it off to clear the tracks faster

Youtube has a lot of them.

Here's one about a derailment in Nashville. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0dZT7TTQqb4

Here's the one I mentioned about a derailment in middle of nowhere Iowa that dumped tar into the creek. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-HpL0Xk9jTI

Here's one of those local news reports: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1_pKVdv-Y6Y

thanks!
Probably because it was literally visible from space (one it was lit on fire).