Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by georgyo 1214 days ago
Npm, yarn, yarn2, pnp, pnpm, and more.

The only thing they have in common is package.json, but even then they can interpret things differently, such as workspaces.

And then node_modules, which packages should not rely on but do, forcing many other tools into compatibility mode which often takes an install take a very long time.

Yes, the node ecosystem is very healthy.
1 comments
michaelcampbell 1214 days ago
> And then node_modules, which packages should not rely on but do,

Isn't the point of node_modules to house ... dependencies? I'm confused as to what you're getting at here.

link
azornathogron 1214 days ago
Various packages rely on node_modules existing as a directory with a particular layout, some rely on being able to write into it. Some of the npm alternatives are built to store and manage dependencies in other ways (e.g., keep packages as zip files or other archives and get node to load direct from the zip), and these other mechanisms do not use a node_modules directory, hence compatibility problems.
link
michaelcampbell 1214 days ago
> these other mechanisms do not use a node_modules directory,

Once you've landed on a package manager that does use it, wouldn't you continue to use that?

link
georgyo 1214 days ago
It doesn't matter if you decide to use a different package manager, if one of your dependencies depend on that layout, you must supply that layout.
link
llanowarelves 1214 days ago
I think he prefers a python-esque way where they're sort of dumped in a flat namespace (and not in current project directory), rather than the node_modules way where it's recursively a copy of each thing and its specific exact dependencies, all the way down.

There are ways to not use node_modules, by using newer Yarns for example.

link
georgyo 1214 days ago
> There are ways to not use node_modules, by using newer Yarns for example.

My point was that if you use yarn2 in pmp mode, and you have a dependencies that depends on the node_modules layout being at the same level as package.json, than even if your package manager doesn't not need or use node_modules, it must emulate it so the dependencies can find their files.

link