Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by JohnFen 1223 days ago
You have a great deal more trust in Google than I. I think that if Google lied about this and got caught, the end result wouldn't be that damaging to Google.

Not saying they are lying, of course, but I don't think the incentives against it are as strong as you do.

But then, I'm skeptical enough about privacy policies that I've stopped reading them. The vast majority of them, including the ones I've read from Google, leave more than enough room for the companies to do pretty much anything they want with your data.
2 comments
jsnell 1223 days ago
But this isn't a in situation where the privacy policy is vague, ambiguous, nor leave room to do anything they want.

From https://policies.google.com/privacy?hl=en-US

> We don’t show you personalized ads based on your content from Drive, Gmail, or Photos.

It is a direct and unambiguous statement in plain language saying that Gmail content is not used for ad targeting.

Given your objection was based on an invalid premise, are you now willing to change your opinion?

link
signatoremo 1223 days ago
What is an example of Google’s privacy policies that make you skeptical?
link
JohnFen 1223 days ago
Like most privacy policies (I'm certainly not saying Google is unique here), they include phrases such as:

> We collect information to provide better services to all our users

Which is vague to the point of uselessness. Google could argue that pretty much any purpose they put that information to is to provide better services to all their users.

This sort of thing is why I ignore privacy policies. They tend to have quite a lot of verbiage of that sort. Even when they appear to solidly say they won't do something, often there's wording elsewhere that provides an exception.

The only way I'd put any stock in a privacy policy is if I have my attorney review it and explain to me what it really says (not being a lawyer, I am not capable of adequately interpreting contracts). Since it's entirely unrealistic to have an attorney review every privacy policy, the safest approach is to assume that they allow the company to do whatever they wish in the end.

And that's all assuming that companies put any real effort to adhering to their privacy policies.

link