Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by remote_phone 1222 days ago
The fact that dark matter has never been seen “but it must be there!” is basically the same argument that religious people make. It’s 100% a religious, faith-based argument and non-scientific. There I said it.

There’s an explanation for all of this behavior that we are measuring but saying that it’s something we can’t see but it’s there!! is objectively absurd.

2 comments

This is flat dumb. Imagine that if when we died that we saw a large electrical impulse leaving our body, or that suddenly some amount of mass disappeared. If this discrepancy existed but was completely unexplainable then the 'is there a soul' or 'does god exist' question would be up for question.

It is much the same for dark matter/dark energy. Without the dark matter 'fudge factor' cosmic observations at galactic scales or above are broken. We've also when and by observation removed a number of things that this fudge factor cannot be. And yet in our observations this fudge factor keeps existing and is found groups like the bullet cluster, or in a small number of galaxies that appear to have no dark matter.

There is not a single reputable scientist that says they know what 'dark matter' is. Scientists know that there are knowledge holes that exist here. They do say it is measurable and that you the denier cannot handwave it away without bringing forth a better theory.

Why is not interacting with EM absurd?