[pas]

How about introducing three dahses for these custom parameters/flags?

Regarding filtering. In a busybox situation depending on some regex crate is a given anyway, but if we are talking about separate binaries adding it to `ls` makes it bigger for everyone, even for those who will never use this feature. Does piping the results to grep make things so much slower that adding filtering to ls is "worth it"? Is this pushing the "philosophy" of do one thing well and be compostable too much? How many kilobytes are we talking about anyway?

Care to share your opinion on these theoretical/pragmatic questions? Thanks!

[terts]

It's possible I suppose, but three dashes already sometimes appears in GNU for hidden options and, probably more importantly, I think it would be frustrating to have to remember whether it was `--filter` or `---filter` for all long flags.

[zaarn]

Maybe uutils could have a build feature that specifically turns off the prefix matching and will break stuff but allows using newer and more useful flags in exchange. I've VERY rarely seen prefix-matched flags being used so I'd wager a distro could be fine deploying it that way.

Ie, setup the features "gnu-compatible-opt-matching" and ship it by default, then gate the extra features behind not turning on that feature.

[terts]

It's a good idea to make the prefix matching optional. I think it might be confusing to gate other features behind it though. I guess we'll get to this once we find flags that are important enough. So far, we haven't really had significant issues with this; compatibility remains our primary focus for now.

[terts]

> In a busybox situation depending on some regex crate is a given anyway

uutils can behave as a busybox-like binary. But I think there's some confusion over the requested feature, because that can't really be done with regex, but you have to inspect the file metadata to check the type of file. That's also why a grep solution doesn't really work, unless you use `ls --classify` and then use the indicators to filter in `grep`.

> if we are talking about separate binaries adding it to `ls` makes it bigger for everyone, even for those who will never use this feature

It's generally not these kinds of features that increase the binary size, but if it does we could also introduce feature flags for it, where you can choose at compile time whether you want the uutils extensions or not. It still adds a bit of a maintenance burden of course.