Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by kierenj 1232 days ago
"The car crashed into the wall" vs "The car quickly sped into the wall"?

Crashed means you don't need to specify it was quick?

3 comments

That's one of the examples that could help you spot non-native speakers (me included).

I would regularly say: "I ran home as fast as possible", while a native speaker would just use: "I rushed home".

On the second reading, my first sentence may read: "That's one of the examples that give out non-native speakers".

i would say simply "i ran home." if what you want to indicate is running using your legs. "rushed" could mean all sorts of things, but might also be good.
Off topic but perhaps not completely since we're discussing clear written expression: "died in an car accident" is the default rendering of such an event in news reports, yet "died in a car crash" is more accurate. What makes a crash an "accident" by default? I have long believed this is powerful manipulation by the car and oil industries to lesson the impact — as it were — of the word "crash."
I think it's more the legal notion of intent that separates manslaughter versus murder. I would venture to say most car crashes that aren't attacks are not intentional, therefore they are accidental. Also if you experience a fatal accident in a car, it's likely enough to be a crash - so I would also venture to say most people understand "car accident" to strongly imply "crash".
Ah, therein lies the rub: implying something softens the unconscious blow. Much science underlies meaning.
i agree that "quickly sped" is horrible, but to set up the crash, you need to establish the speed of the car beforehand.
I would say that "quickly sped" is bad merely because it's redundant. Nobody "slowly speeds".