Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by moffkalast 1227 days ago
> 193.110.81.0

Ah yes, easy to remember /s

5 comments

212.142.28.66 is an IP address of a DNS server that has been stuck in my mind for 25 years now. That said the time where anyone would regularly configure DNS settings is long gone I imagine.
You lived in a pre-smartphone era, which has made the rest of us dumb...
Why do you need to remember the dns server address? I just type it in once.
Once on every device, VM, container, VPS, etc. That's a lot of times.
My devices get their dns servers via DHCP. So I enter it only once on the DHCP server.

If you’re running so many devices, you probably want to use your own DNS server too (for internal name resolution), so you can also set the upstream just there.

I feel your pain but if you really have so many machines you probably automate their configuration.
Or, setup everything to use a resolver on your router, configure your router once. So when you want to change in the future, only one place.
That's what things like Ansible and VM base images are for.
The era of easy to remember DNS server addresses is coming to a close anyway, due to IPv6.

Cloudflare’s are 2606:4700:4700:1001:: and 2606:4700:4700:1111::

I’ve been deploying IPv6 recently and these addresses haven’t burnt into my brains yet, so I occasionally have to do `dig AAAA one.one.one.one` still.

Coming soon: my public IPv6 dns at dead:beef::
Mine will be b00b:: once IANA assigns me b00b::/16
Not everyone has the resources of a Google to acquire lucky IP addresses.
If you have no working DNS, it's hard to google stuff...

There are two types of people - those that just want dns to work at all so they can get stuff done, and those who have working dns but want to 'upgrade' for privacy/filtering reasons.

Well you'd think the EU would have more resources than a single company.
This is not something from the EU as the organization, but from a French non-profit.
So in short, they're completely noncredible. I'm not sure who in the right mind would trust a random small company with their DNS.
They're not random, they're a French non-profit (created by cofounders of nextdns, btw). Why wouldn't people trust them? In my country most people use a DNS hosted by their ISP, and there are a lot of small ISPs all around. I suspect it's similar everywhere. How is it different?

And anyway, I trust a random French small company more than I trust Google.

Well yes exactly, the only reason you'd switch to a trusted service over a default is to hopefully shield from DNS poisoning and other shenanigans. It would need to be a proven trustworthy service, and just about anyone with a few hours of spare time and literally no cash can open a French NGO, they've got the lowest barrier for entry of any EU country. Just slapping on a nextdns logo doesn't mean shit. It's completely pointless unless it's an EU official government service financed directly by our tax dollars.

Google has a reputation to uphold, so while you can be certain they'll be datamining the shit out of your requests they are also unlikely to be direct malicious actors.

Most of those single digit addresses are in the hands of US corporations. Like 4.4.4.4 is Level 3.
2.0.0.0/16 and 2.2.0.0/16 are owned by Orange, a European company. I'm sure they'd be willing to lease 2.2.2.0/24 and 2.0.0.0/24 for a nominal fee

5.4.0.0/14 (so 5.5.5.5) is Telefonica Germany. Same thing there.

Mercedes owns 53.0.0.0/8 which feels like a nice number for DNS too.

Telefonica and Orange are hardly companies that would just let you lease "valuable" ipv4 addresses without having to pay a hefty sum.
If you only lease something the owner can at any time take your business and efforts from you.
It's not the IP that's the problem.

It's the "anycast" mapping of the IP to geographically and network diverse hosts to connect the user to the "closest" (for some value of latency that stays within the data governance jurisdiction).

To do this, you basically have to own a large enough IP block that backbones will deal with it, and route map it.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anycast

This is not "the EU", just an EU NGO offering up the service.
This isn't run by the EU.
My phone number is a little longer and yet I remember it, along with my own public IP address as well as my physical one. It depends how much you need to use it, of course.
I rarely phone myself. When my number changes, it takes me about a year before I can remember the new one. Numbers I actually call are much easier to memorize.