Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by DannyBee 1224 days ago
Err, no. The buttons are not wired anymore. All buttons are battery powered remotes, even wall pads. This is how it's done now - the manufacturer does not ship any hardwired buttons for these models (Genie 6170)

Not sure why everyone keeps making assertions about the setup instead of asking questions. First claims that it's a line of sight safety device (which is wrong), now weird claims about physical proximity (which are also wrong).

Zero of the manufacturer shipped mechanisms to open or close these require physical proximity. Someone can open the door while i am in there using the remote, etc. It works fine from 300 feet away, and in fact, it's quite common for it to be opened or closed while someone is 150ft away at the bottom of the driveway.

We also had a wall pad in the house that triggers the garage, also (it's no longer needed but we started with one).

Wifi is no better or worse here - So i still maintain having a device that does not trigger all the time, despite lack of physical proximity, but instead based on whether it's FSK or wifi, is confusing and pointless

It's also more unsafe.