Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by andys627 1234 days ago
I intuitively agree but have learned that "Cities should be able to plan their own growth." is just too simplistic.
2 comments

City planning is much too simplistic for the metropolises of California. Region planning is more apt.
The other lesson might be that 'city' is too broad a term. Some cities are standalone, some are just arbitrary boundaries within a metropolis. Maybe the latter should be eliminated and replaced with a metropolis-wide city.
Agreed, there should be a strict framework within such planning happens, to avoid the housing crisis that CA cities have created for those that don't own land. Japan is a great inspiration for planning like this. US planning, the entire field, is absolutely abhorrent, and should really be scrapped and rebuilt from scratch.