Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by nineteen999 1242 days ago
As usual, ChatGPT is summarizing and regurgitating the (m|d)isinformation that's already out there.

It doesn't matter how many Tlon employees and Urbit fans protest otherwise, that what is inaccurate. Urbit is not an "operating system".

Here's the download page, where you can download Urbit for Linux, Urbit for MacOS, Urbit for Windows etc:

https://urbit.org/getting-started/cli

It's an application. It's not an "operating system". You need an operating system to run it.

It's also not a "personal server operating function" or "new kind of computer" as described elsewhere in the literature. It's a freaking web app.

I love that the CLI installation instructions describe themselves as "Installation instructions for power users". On the home page "All the smart people I know disappear into Urbit."

This is toy software, backed by a 100% transparent ponzi scheme, appealing to the most gullible out there who desperately want to be accepted by a "smart" minority group.

The network is more resilient to censorship, surveillance, and data breaches? Puhlease. The CLI example page shows you how to set up a basic Urbit instance which is accessed via ... unencrypted HTTP.

1 comments

>Urbit is not an "operating system".

Agree, term is wrongly used. Here it is used in the literal meaning of it. A software stack upon which you can execute other apps. The original concept iirc was to run both natively and overlayed but seems they've settled down to just the later.

>It's a freaking web app.

You can use Urbit without ever touching the web app and the neworking protocol is independent of http.

We want to get to native, but you don’t replace the hardware in a day. It doesn’t make sense to build a custom nock cpu until it’s necessary.

For a new system to succeed it has to run on the hardware people have. That’s why there’s a runtime. It is an OS, but there’s an interpreter for the machines of today. If urbit succeeds then running it directly would be the ultimate goal.