Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by chamwislothe2nd 1243 days ago
Every midjourney image has the same feeling to it. A bit 1950s sci-fi artist. I guess it's just that it all looks airbrushed? I can't put my finger on it.
3 comments

Yeah, I think Midjourney makes fewer unsuccessful images, but harder to get images that dont match their particular style.
I don't know if that was Midjourney's intent, but it seems like a smart approach. Instead of trying to be everything to everyone and generating quite a lot of ugly garbage, you get consistently good-looking stuff in a certain style. I'm sure it helps their business model.
Feels like it's the Instagram model for prompt-generated images.

Anyone can get a camera phone, take a picture and use some free software (e.g. gimp) to get great results in post-processing.

Most non-expert users though want to click on a few pre-defined filters, find one they like & run with it, rather than having more control yet poorer results (precisely because they _aren't_ experts).

It's the science magazine article illustration look.
Sounds great

If Midjourney applies this to all their artwork then maybe it alleviates some of the ethical concerns (Midjourney then has a "style" independent of the training data)

But the style isn't independent of training data. If you don't feed Midjourney images in that style, it's not going to come up with it independently.
I've played a lot with it lately and that just not true. If you play with styles, colors, angles, views you have a lot of control about how the imagine will look. It can emulate pretty much all mainstream aesthetics.