Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by GenericDev 1241 days ago
You do not speak for me. I want decentralization, self hosting, and the right to repair. The modern technology ecosystem has failed me in every one of these areas.
1 comments

GP may not speak for you, but they do speak for 99.9% of users. How’d the whole Mastodon migration go? Seems to have fizzled.
I don't use twitter or mastodon, so I consider it a significant sign that I keep seeing so many of my peers and people whose content I read showing up on Mastodon. I consider myself impartial. That's just n=1 from my perspective, but it's a datapoint nonetheless considering I'm the least likely to be exposed to this.
Mastodon has a very decent user base, and recently expanded very significantly. For me that is enough.
For you, yes, but not for other people which is the whole point. The fact that Mastodon couldn't truly ride the biggest opportunity they will ever have says it all.
What do you mean? Mastodon rode it quite well to the point that servers were straining under the load.

Twitter still exists and is still functional, so why would absolutely everyone move over? I don't think that's ever happened. Every system I've seen where people migrated over elsewhere had it happen over a long period of time.

Mastodon doesn’t speak for decentralization
>Mastodon doesn’t speak for decentralization

That's kind of the point, IMHO.

Mastodon doesn't speak for decentralization, it is decentralized. And that's not really splitting hairs here, it's an important distinction.

I could set up a Mastodon instance (although Writefreely[1] and Pixelfed[2] are more my speed) that advocated for centralized everything. I could even ban folks who argue for decentralization and delete any comments they make in favor of same.

It's a tool that allows folks to speak for themselves, without a central corporate authority dictating what's acceptable and what isn't.

If you don't like a particular Fediverse[0] instance, move to another one or set one up for yourself.

[0] https://fediverse.party/

[1] https://writefreely.org/

[2] https://fediverse.party/en/pixelfed/