[jacquesm]

If you take it as read that YC is not run by complete idiots then you may also realize that they probably made some effort to ensure that their decision was the right one. That you aren't privilege to that information is perfectly fine, they are under no obligation to open the books on their selection process and/or on any assistance provided to Sam afterwards. The main giveaway is that you think that a successful YC alumn by your standard would automatically be more qualified to run YC, which is not at all like any one of the companies that YC has invested in. Besides that unless a company exists a typical YC alumn will be running their company, which is typically a >> full time job for those companies that are successful.