[ShredKazoo]

>a deluge of bills from providers who have no idea what the insurance owes and what you owe.

But if the provider can't communicate with the insurance in order to figure that out, why would a different deductible/coinsurance change that?

I was actually told that I met my deductible in 2022, and then I got another big bill in the mail. So that made me think deductibles are a scam and I should just pick the plan with the lowest premium.

(Thanks a lot for answering my questions by the way!)

[maxerickson]

The deductible is one of two thresholds that are typical on insurance plans. The second, higher threshold is the out of pocket maximum.

So some aspect of the coverage might be a 20% coinsurance, where you pay the full cost up to the deductible and then pay 20% of the cost after that until you have reached the out of pocket maximum.

Most of the fees you pay count against both of them, so like if you pay $35 to visit your primary care doctor, you are $35 closer to meeting your deductible, and then also $35 closer to reaching your out of pocket maximum. Lots of frequently used services are covered as a fee based co-pay rather than as coinsurance.

If you have a major expense for something that is covered as 20% coinsurance, the amount up to the deductible would be 100% out of your pocket, and then the coverage would kick in and pay for 80% of the rest (until your 20% exceeds the out of pocket maximum).

I kind of wonder if disallowing insurance companies to negotiate deals with providers would actually end up improving things a lot (because it would create pressure to normalize prices vs fucking around to save a little bit).