Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by senttoschool 1251 days ago
Your comment is so weird. China has not shown colonial mindset in the last few hundred years. Even when it had by far, the highest GDP country in the world, it did not colonize other countries.

All China wants is for North Korea to not collapse because that would create a huge humanitarian crisis at its borders.

Also, Chinese people are more practical. Leave this problem to the Chinese and they’ll find a way to solve it that does not involve sending its army to Haiti. They’re not warmongers like Americans are.

2 comments

> China has not shown colonial mindset in the last few hundred years.

So, the annexation of Tibet and the repopulation of Xinjiang didn't happen?

> All China wants is for North Korea to not collapse

That must be why they bully their smaller neighbours.

> Also, Chinese people are more practical.

Right. Like we saw with the spectacular success of Zero-Covid and their refusal to authorise foreign mRNA vaccines.

> They’re not warmongers like Americans are.

That must be why they keep violating the Line of Control and firing missiles over Taiwan.

China does not invade countries the same way European and American countries do in the last few hundreds of years. Past that, I do not know enough about history.

I'm not sure how you can dispute this.

Chinese people do not yearn for war like Americans and Europeans do.

Taiwan is a disputed territory and the US has been provoking China intensely in the last few years. Obama administration got it right. Trump and Biden have not. If the US was in China's position, it would have authorized a Taiwan invasion decades ago.

The first instinct for Americans in any international conflict is how soon can we send a couple of fighter jets and blow some stuff up.

The first instinct for the Chinese is how can we hash this out without any physical violence. The second instinct is the same as the first. The 3rd instinct is the same as the first. And if you have to make it to the 4th instinct, then it's all out war. This mindset reflected in Chinese culture and Chinese Americans as well. Chinese people have a lot of patience when it comes to violence. But if you provoke them enough, they're willing to lose everything to make a point.

This is the reason why I believe China will be a better world police enforcer than America.

Perhaps you have not visited the border at arunachal pradesh, or aksai chin. Both are indian territories forcibly occupied by the Chinese.

We (at India) have fought wars in the past 50 years to protect our land from the Chinese invaders.

Furthermore, leaving India aside, let's think about Tibet, the uighur muslims for a moment.

The current Dalai Lama is in exile also.

I don't think disputed territories are considered as colonial. I think you need to stay objective even if this is you (Indian) vs China.

Tibet has been with China since 7th century according to a quick wikipedia search.

Nothing I said in my original comment is dissuaded by your arguments. If you think so, then you should study more European colonial (GB colonized India) and Chinese history.