[dktoao]

Yes, that is the process of "civilization" that he is talking about in the article. I'm starting to think that some of these comments are generated by someone typing "Give me a really generic conservative argument against UBI" into ChatGPT.

[kodyo]

The arguments for it aren't impressive either.

[dktoao]

What arguments for it? I scanned this entire thread and I don't see a single one.

[andorov]

I'm not presenting an argument against UBI - I am pointing out that his argument is flawed.

Small tribes of humans defending hunting/foraging grounds is a state of pre-civilization. Life required work then too, and things were worse. His premise is that things used to be better and we've made it worse. Hard disagree.