Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by CyanLite4 1251 days ago
L3 driving is only available at low speeds, approx 35mph which means only useful for stop-and-go traffic. Many cars with adaptive cruise control can already do this.

Source: https://www.rambus.com/blogs/driving-automation-levels/#leve...

4 comments

The public page makes no such distinction[0].

I created a mySAE account to download the full spec. What I found is that the manufacturer generally has fairly free reign to define their "operational design domain (ODD)" for level 3 systems, aka what conditions the car's "level 3" operation is designed for and can operate under. The only real requirement for level 3 is that OEDR is required (monitoring the driving environment (detecting, recognizing, and classifying objects and events and preparing to respond as needed) and executing an appropriate response to such objects and events (i.e., as needed to complete the DDT and/or DDT fallback [fallback to driver]).

0: https://www.sae.org/blog/sae-j3016-update

Those are SAE’s criteria but I wonder what Federal and state DoT’s have to say about the matter.

Props to SAE for making their spec free do download, modulo a gratuitous account.

The big difference is MB is taking liability in the event of a collision and he car won’t simply hand control back to the driver. This is much more advanced than any L2 system and the fact MB is taking liability is a whole different ballpark.
> L3 driving is only available at low speeds, approx 35mph

In that case, this paragraph from the article doesn't make much sense (in fairness, it was on pretty shaky ground to begin with):

> Mercedes’ Level 3 conditionally automated driving assistant can, on suitable highway sections [emphasis added] and where traffic density is high, offer to take over the driving, leaving the driver free to do something else, like watch a movie or participate in a meeting.

Highways during rush hour in many cities have traffic that moves very slowly for many miles/hours. This L3 is perfect for those situations where people are reading books during the stop and go.
It's for people stuck in traffic on a congested highway.
Then why does the article claim Mercedes is the first automaker to offer L3 driving?
The difference is the confidence level. The required level of supervision. Other cars, like Teslas, can “do” this task, but not with enough certainty that they are safe to do it while not being actively monitored by a driver.
Teslas did this years ago. The standard autopilot could do this, at speeds up to 100miles/hour.

Later, they add the nag. 2018 I think.

Yes, at SAE J3016 level 2.