Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by thatguy0900 1260 days ago
Even more funny how you can't even ask the government in advance how a particular situation would be resolved, as courts don't rule on hypothetical situations. People on the cutting edge in a lot of spaces really just have to do it and find out the legality later.
2 comments

Not quite true, you can request an administrative ruling in many circumstances.

https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-31/subtitle-B/chapter-X/p...

How could it possible for a court to "pre settle" a dispute between 2 private parties , based on only one side presenting their case?

Eh, mock trials are very common. I had a family member that was paid to be a juror in an IP trial in East Texas that was testing the waters.
That's different. That's one side of a trial practicing - presenting a case to a mock jury to see what flies and what doesn't.

What GP is asking for is a way to get an actual decision from an actual court, before it's needed.